Just how many research students should we be supervising?

Just how many research students should we be supervising?

This was part of a conversation I had last weekend with a senior academic. We were discussing various approaches to rationalising an answer, but also the perspectives and approach different Universities take in establishing guidelines.

Between research, lecturing, departmental and faculty obligations (committees, etc), there isn’t really a lot of time remaining for supervision. An educated guestimate by both of us that 5 research students in a year would be considered a healthy contribution to the future of academia, accounting for approximately 25% of ones’ time – we agreed that such a proportion would not be unheard of.

Fast forward until yesterday. Change location and context to Malaysia. And what did I see, a local private university advertising for a supervisory-based senior position – to work with research students as a supervisor at post graduate levels.

The expectation: supervise up to twelve (12) students within an equivalency of three (3) days per week, AND … network to promote the school, mentor and support others, and publish. Quite a big ask in relation to the quality of focused input that one would hope is achieved.

We knew the pressure was on in Asia, but how does this result in relevant and productive supervision outcomes for research students?

Ignore the issue that the discipline was left purposefully wide – a generic supervision blanket to enable students to have an on-campus (or on-zoom) supervisor for both Masters and PhD – tick the box rather than contribute specifically – not a guarantee that the supervisor can strategically contribute to the student research per se.

What it does is add justification to what we are doing at #TheThirdDegree. Investment in our #ResearchStudents is essential for the future. Don’t skimp on that investment, either financially, or with allocation of time and other resources.

Interested on your feedback as to ideal number of students to supervise, and how you balance that from semester-to-semester, to ensure consistent outcomes for your students.

#PostGraduateResearch #ResearchSupervision #AcademicWorkLifeBalance #Universities

Comments

Defending THE Institution?

Defending THE Institution? Maybe I am trying to defend a fallen castle, but I don’t quite believe it’s at that stage yet! While applauding businesses, big and small, embracing alternative qualifications to facilitate employment opportunities, one must remember that the University itself is not only a centre of learning – it is an entire socialisation and networking experience that has significant value-add over and above the content of learning and assessment. Encouraging short or modular online learning is perfectly fine, but we must not kid ourselves that it provides a holistic approach – either to topic or to social inclusion. Nor does it pave the way to successful remote working. There’s far more to those jig-saw puzzles than just a course. There will always be value in a full university degree. Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater just yet. __________ Google Plan To Replace The Need For College Degrees With Six-month ...

Dear New PhD Student

Dear New PhD Student Dear New PhD Student This is an exciting time for you as you embark on your journey towards a doctoral degree. As your supervisor, I thought I should write to welcome you and give you a few handy hints that may help both of us to survive this long journey. We both have much to learn. Although we have exchanged emails, we do not know each other well. I feel at the outset, we have to display the good in us, and hide the crazy. Over the next three years this balance will switch, as we each reveal our true selves. My role is to guide you through the minefield that is the modern research process. You will learn how to identify gaps in knowledge, critically review literature, pose useful research questions, devise testable hypotheses, acquire the necessary ethical approvals, collect and analyse data and so on. But remember I am not your sister, nor your mother, nor am I your counsellor – I am not your friend either. Some supervisors regularly socialis...

Upcoming Webinars | June & July 2021

Upcoming Webinars | June & July 2021 For the remainder of June, plus the four (4) weeks in July, we have a series of webinars that focus on approaches to research, literature, and research communication. The webinar topics are applicable to early and mid-journey PhD candidates, but anyone thinking of, or nearing completion of their journey are welcome to attend. Wednesday 23 June 2021 | Introduction to Observational Research Facilitator | Dr Craig J Selby Observational research allows the researcher to see what their subjects really do when confronted with various choices or situations. As the name implies, is a way of collecting data through observing – either directly or indirectly – but either way, the researcher has an active involvement in the process. Observation data collection method is classified as a participatory study, as the researcher immerses themselves in the setting where the respondents are. Register Here: https://www.eventbrite...

The Third Degree

Search This Blog